Sustainability Software

ESG Benchmarking: A Guide to Comparing Your Performance Against Peers

Did you know that companies with better Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) performance often outperform their competitors? A review of more than 1,000 studies by NYU Stern and Rockefeller Asset Management found a positive link between ESG and financial performance in 58% of corporate studies.

The power of ESG benchmarking is that it helps your company understand exactly where it stands on its ESG goals and strategies relative to competitors, customers, and ESG leaders. Knowing where you stand lets you make better decisions to meet and exceed your competitors' ESG performance.

Put simply, ESG benchmarking is a temperature check on how your current ESG program compares to competitors and others, and it helps shape your future strategy. Whether you want to keep pace with competitors or pull ahead and become a top performer among ESG leaders, benchmarking is an essential tool to help you get there.

What is ESG?

Environmental, Social, and Governance, or ESG, is a collective term for how companies assess their sustainability performance across a series of metrics, such as carbon emissions, hazardous waste, human rights, diversity, compliance, and many more. Measuring ESG data is also a way to measure the risks facing your business, whether that is climate or water risk, or the risk of new legislation on human rights or disclosure.

Collecting ESG data helps you identify and mitigate risk and take advantage of potential opportunities. Reporting ESG metrics, strategies, and targets builds trust, transparency, and accountability with customers, suppliers, investors, and other stakeholders.

What is ESG Benchmarking?

ESG benchmarking, also called sustainability benchmarking, is the process of comparing and evaluating your company's ESG performance against competitors, customers, and industry leaders. Benchmarking is essential for identifying opportunities to improve your business, products, or services and staying competitive with industry leaders.

Why is ESG Benchmarking Important?

Just like any other type of benchmarking, ESG benchmarking lets you see what is happening across the competitive landscape. It gives you context on your ESG strategy, targets, and performance, and it guides decisions about your future ESG strategy.

Benchmarking also lets stakeholders, including investors, customers, and employees, see where your performance ranks in your sector. A strong benchmark position could be the difference between hiring an employee, winning a contract, or receiving investment.

How EcoVadis and CDP Benchmark You for Your Customers

Even if you have never run a benchmarking exercise, your customers are probably already benchmarking you. There are many types of ESG benchmarking tools. The two most common ways are EcoVadis and CDP.

EcoVadis awards companies that report medals based on the percentile rank of their ESG score. The score you need for a medal rises as other companies improve, which they do every year. In our analysis of EcoVadis medal thresholds, every medal cutoff climbed six to eight points in roughly two years. More than 1,300 companies use EcoVadis to assess the ESG performance of thier suppliers. New to EcoVadis? Start with our EcoVadis 101 guide.

CDP scores companies from A to D-, and most scores are public, so any buyer can compare you with your competitors. Our CDP reporting guide explains how scoring works.

Benchmarking yourself against peers on the same criteria shows you where you are losing points before your next assessment. That is one of the methods Brock Group used to improve its EcoVadis score by 23 points in a single cycle.

What are the Benefits of ESG Benchmarking?

The benefits of ESG benchmarking may seem difficult to quantify, but there are both tangible and less tangible benefits to starting the process. They include:

  • ESG performance evaluation: ESG benchmarking lets companies evaluate their performance against peers, customers, and suppliers, and against industry and regional averages. By comparing their ESG practices, companies can identify where they excel and where they need to improve.
  • Risk assessment and mitigation: ESG benchmarking helps companies identify and assess risks tied to ESG factors, from brand reputation damage and lost deals to competitors to climate risk. This lets them develop strategies to mitigate those risks proactively.
  • Better stakeholder confidence: ESG benchmarking can strengthen a company's reputation and transparency, increasing investor, customer, and employee confidence. By demonstrating strong ESG performance against peers, companies can attract investment and talent and grow their customer base.
  • Potential cost savings and increased revenue: ESG benchmarking can show where competitors have made efficiencies, reduced waste, or won contracts. Companies can adapt those practices to reduce energy use and waste, which leads to cost savings over time.

Key Components of Performing Effective ESG Benchmarking

To understand which ESG factors and metrics matter, companies should perform a materiality assessment alongside their benchmarking. A materiality assessment identifies the factors most relevant to your business and stakeholders. 

These could include environmental metrics like greenhouse gas emissions, water use, or waste; social metrics like employee diversity, labor practices, or community engagement; and governance metrics like board diversity, executive compensation, or risk management.

Once you know which ESG factors to assess your performance on, you can take these three steps to get an external pulse check through effective ESG benchmarking:

  1. ESG data collection and comparison: First, set up a robust internal data collection plan so you understand where your progress lies. Then compare your data to relevant benchmarks, such as industry peers or sector averages. Choosing the right peers matters: comparing yourself only with the largest companies in your sector will set targets you cannot reach.
  2. Analysis, planning, and ESG target setting: Analyze the gaps between you and your competitors alongside your materiality assessment. This guides how ambitious your ESG goals should be. Accurate target setting helps you quantify your aspirations in each important area and shapes your strategy for measuring and reducing ESG impacts.
  3. Monitoring and reporting: Once you have set goals and begun tracking progress, report that progress in your annual ESG or sustainability report. Reporting on your goals, strategies, and actions builds trust and accountability. Benchmarks move every year, so continual monitoring makes sure you don't fall behind.

Alternatively, many companies start benchmarking because a customer sends a supplier questionnaire or asks them to report through a framework like EcoVadis or CDP. In those cases, the questions, process, and scoring method are already defined. Because every company is assessed against the same criteria, the results are also easier to compare.

Whichever route applies, Good.Lab's ESG benchmarking tool does the comparison work for you. It shows:

  • Where your EcoVadis score stands against industry peers and top performers.
  • Which CDP disclosure gaps are most common in your sector, and how yours compare.
  • How your GHG emissions profile compares with peers, category by category across Scope 1, 2, and 3.
  • What competitors are committing to, drawn from a database of 3,000+ industry targets.

You get an accurate benchmark in days instead of weeks, with our consultants on hand to interpret the gaps and turn them into a plan.

ESG Benchmarking Case Study

To help apparel manufacturer and merchandiser Bioworld Merchandising meet its aspiration "to be a leader in the sustainability space," Good.Lab performed extensive ESG benchmarking. The work assessed Bioworld's ESG program scope and performance relative to customers, competitors, and peers; which ESG targets to set; and which ESG metrics to collect and report.

Conducting ESG benchmarking with Good.Lab enabled us to focus and prioritize our efforts around key impact areas and to build a data-backed foundation for tracking ESG progress."

Jason Mayes, Director of Marketing & Intellectual Property, Bioworld Merchandising

To learn how Good.Lab guided Bioworld through an end-to-end ESG program launch, read the full Bioworld case study.

What's Next in ESG Benchmarking

The value of ESG benchmarking for improving a company's ESG performance is clear. However, two common criticisms of ESG are the lack of a consistent standard for making comparisons and the lack of accurate data. Both are now being addressed.

  • ESG data standardization: More jurisdictions are aligning their sustainability reporting with the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB). S&P Global counted 28 jurisdictions that had adopted the ISSB standards as of April 2026, with 12 more planning to do so. In the EU, the ESG Ratings Regulation has applied since July 2, 2026, requiring ESG rating providers to be authorized and to disclose their methodologies. In the US, California's SB 253 and SB 261 require large companies doing business in the state to disclose their emissions and climate risks, creating a new set of public disclosures to benchmark against.
  • ESG data quality: As ESG data becomes more important for decision-making, there is a greater focus on data quality, accuracy, and transparency. SB 253 phases in third-party assurance of emissions data from 2027. To keep up, more companies are using software to record and report their data to meet expectations for more detailed, verifiable ESG information.

Discover How You Measure Up on ESG

At Good.Lab, we can help you perform both a materiality assessment and benchmarking to give you a full picture of best practices for building a winning ESG program.

Our ESG benchmarking assessment pairs that software with expert guidance, so you can see what ESG leaders, competitors, customers, and suppliers are doing and calibrate your own targets with confidence.

The sooner you start benchmarking and see where you sit among competitors, customers, and suppliers, the easier it will be to catch up and adapt to future trends. Reach out today to start benchmarking and stay competitive.

FAQs

What is ESG benchmarking?

ESG benchmarking is the process of measuring your organization's environmental, social, and governance performance against industry standards or peers. It helps you identify strengths, uncover areas for improvement, and demonstrate transparency to stakeholders, investors, and customers. This data-driven approach supports better decision-making and builds long-term business resilience.

What is the difference between an ESG benchmark and ESG benchmarking?

In finance, an ESG benchmark usually means an index used to measure investment performance. ESG benchmarking for companies compares your own performance and targets against peers. The reference points you compare against, such as an industry average, are often also called ESG benchmarks.

What are the benefits of ESG benchmarking?

By adopting ESG benchmarking, you gain actionable insights into your sustainability performance, which can improve operational efficiency, strengthen brand reputation, and increase investor confidence. It can also help you meet regulatory requirements and position your company as a responsible leader in your sector.

Who should use ESG benchmarking?

ESG benchmarking is valuable for organizations of all sizes, across industries. Whether you're a small business beginning your sustainability journey or a large enterprise with established ESG practices, benchmarking gives you a clear framework to measure progress and identify best practices to stay competitive.

How often should companies benchmark their ESG performance?

Most organizations benefit from benchmarking annually to track progress and adjust strategies as needed. That also lines up with EcoVadis scores, which are valid for 12 months, and CDP's annual disclosure cycle. Depending on your industry, regulatory requirements, and stakeholder expectations, more frequent assessments may help you respond to emerging trends and challenges.

How does Good.Lab approach ESG benchmarking?

Good.Lab's ESG benchmarking combines industry-specific data, advanced analytics, and practical insights tailored to your organization's goals. Our approach goes beyond compliance, helping you embed sustainability into your core strategy and achieve meaningful, measurable impact.

‍

Long heading is what you see here in this feature section

Learn more about our approach to emerging regulations and including SB 261, SB 263 and complete mandatory reporting with ease.

Talk to an expert

Not sure where to start? That's exactly where we come in.

Most of our clients came to us with more questions than answers. That's fine. Tell us what you're navigating and we'll tell you what we'd do first.

Talk to an expert