Sustainability Regulations

California Climate Disclosure Laws Updates from CARB

(Updated as of November 12, 2026)

On November 9, 2026, the Ninth Circuit ruled on the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's challenge to California's climate disclosure laws. SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reporting stays in effect. SB 253 Scope 3 reporting and SB 261 are now on hold.

The California Air Resources Board (CARB) has officially approved the state's climate disclosure laws, SB 253 and SB 261, and continues to issue guidance for companies preparing to comply. This article covers the court ruling, what's required and when, and what to do next.

Key Takeaways

  • SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reporting stays in effect. The Ninth Circuit refused to block it on November 9, 2026. The first reports were due November 10, 2026, and the 2027 limited assurance requirement is unaffected.
  • SB 253 Scope 3 reporting is likely on hold. The court found it likely unconstitutional and sent it back to the trial court to decide whether Scope 3 can be separated from the rest of the law. Until that happens and appeals play out, California will likely not require Scope 3 reporting.
  • SB 261 stays paused. The court confirmed the hold in place since November 2025. No climate-risk report is required while the injunction remains.
  • Fees are still coming. The fee assessment date is December 10, 2026, with a 60-day window to pay. CARB's preliminary estimate is $3,000 to $4,000 per entity (informational only, not finalized).
  • Keep Scope 3 on your roadmap. It's still part of the GHG Protocol and required or expected by CSRD, SBTi, CDP, EcoVadis and customer supplier programs. It could also return on appeal.

The November 9 Ninth Circuit Ruling

In a 2-1 decision in Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, the Ninth Circuit split SB 253 in two. Scope 1 and 2 disclosures move ahead. Scope 3 disclosures and SB 261 are likely to be enjoined as unconstitutional under the First Amendment.

The court's reasoning: Scope 1 and 2 are factual disclosures about a company's own operations and purchased energy. Scope 3 covers the activity of independent third parties across the value chain, and SB 261 calls for more subjective risk assessments. This is a preliminary injunction ruling, not a final decision on whether the laws are constitutional.

What the Court Decided

Requirement Ruling What it means near term
SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 Not blocked; assurance requirement unaffected No change. Your inventory, CARB filing and future limited assurance stay on track.
SB 253 Scope 3 Sent back to the trial court to decide if it can be separated from the rest of SB 253 California will likely not require Scope 3 until that's resolved and appeals play out. Most other frameworks and many customers still expect it under the GHG Protocol.
SB 261 Stay remains in place (paused since November 2025) No climate-risk report is required while the injunction is in place.

What We're Watching

  • The trial court's decision on separating Scope 3 from the rest of SB 253
  • Possible appeals by either side, including a request for rehearing by the full Ninth Circuit or Supreme Court review
  • CARB updates to SB 253 and SB 261 regulations, guidance and reporting deadlines

We'll keep monitoring CARB and the courts and update this article as things develop over the coming months.

SB 253: What's Required and When

SB 253 (the Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act) requires U.S.-based companies with more than $1 billion in annual revenue doing business in California to publicly disclose greenhouse gas emissions. After the November 9 ruling, Scope 1 and 2 requirements remain in force, while Scope 3 is likely on hold.

Reporting Timeline

Year Requirement
2026 Scope 1 and 2 only. First deadline: November 10, 2026.
2027 Scope 1 and 2, with limited assurance required. Scope 3 was scheduled to begin, but is likely on hold following the November 9 ruling.
2030+ Reasonable assurance trajectory for Scope 1 and 2. Scope 3 status depends on the trial court and any appeals.

Who's Exempt

  • Nonprofit and charitable organizations tax-exempt under the Internal Revenue Code
  • Federal, state, and local government entities and majority government-owned companies
  • Companies whose only California activity is wholesale electricity transactions
  • Companies whose only California nexus is employee compensation or payroll, including remote workers

What "Doing Business in California" Means

CARB removed the earlier property-holdings and payroll criteria. The standard now is whether a company financially benefits from transactions in the state or is domiciled there. CARB released a preliminary list of covered entities in September 2025, but has confirmed this list is a rough estimate only, not a determination. Companies should independently assess whether they meet the revenue and California-nexus thresholds.

Which Fiscal Year to Report

Your reporting year for the first SB 253 filing depends on your fiscal year end:

  • Fiscal year ending between January 1 and February 1, 2026: report emissions from the FY ending in 2026.
  • Fiscal year ending between February 2 and December 31, 2026: report emissions from the FY ending in 2025.

How to Submit: CARB's September 1 Guidance

CARB's September 1 release answered the "how do we actually file" question. There are three acceptable submission paths, and CARB has not indicated a preference among them:

  1. CARB's voluntary intake platform: no account required; submit contact and billing information and Scope 1 and 2 data directly.
  2. An existing report or dataset: an annual report or data already submitted through another program or voluntary initiative.
  3. CARB's October 2025 draft template: remains voluntary for 2026.

If your company wasn't collecting Scope 1 and 2 data as of the December 5, 2024 enforcement notice, CARB requests a non-reporting statement on company letterhead instead. This carries reputational and contractual risk, since it signals a company is not yet tracking its emissions.

A few additional points from the guidance:

  • A full sustainability report isn't required. A concise document with your Scope 1 and 2 emissions and company information satisfies the requirement.
  • Submissions, whether through the portal or by email to climatedisclosure@arb.ca.gov, become public within 90 days of receipt.
  • Fees: the assessment date moved from September 10 to December 10, 2026, to align with the new deadline. Entities have 60 calendar days to pay after assessment. CARB's preliminary, informational-only estimate is $3,000 to $4,000 per entity.

Draft Scope 1 and 2 Reporting Template

CARB's October 2025 draft reporting template remains voluntary for 2026 but offers useful structure. It includes sections for:

  • Organization information
  • Third-party verification
  • Inventory boundary
  • Scope 1 and Scope 2 disclosure
  • Methodology
  • De minimis / minor sources
  • California MRR fields (if applicable)
  • Emission reductions (if applicable)

Companies can apply any of the GHG Protocol's three organizational boundary approaches (equity share, operational control, or financial control), provided the choice is disclosed and applied consistently. CARB is also seeking input on whether a single boundary method should eventually be standardized.

Assurance: What's Required, and When

The November 9 ruling does not affect SB 253's assurance requirement for Scope 1 and 2.

  • 2026: No assurance requirement. Report what you have as of the December 5, 2024 enforcement notice, whether that includes assurance or not.
  • 2027: Limited assurance is required for Scope 1 and 2. Companies that already hold reasonable assurance (a higher standard) can submit that instead of arranging a separate limited-assurance engagement.
  • 2030+: Assurance requirements are expected to move toward reasonable assurance for Scope 1 and 2.

Even though assurance isn't mandatory until 2027, treat this year as the time to build the underlying discipline: assign data owners, maintain methodology and change logs, and document estimates and exclusions. Assurance readiness is built through the reporting process itself, not added at the end of it.

Consolidated and Parent/Subsidiary Reporting

A parent may file one consolidated report for its subsidiaries, but this is a filing convenience, not a scope reducer:

  • Applicability is determined per entity, regardless of corporate structure. Each entity independently checks the revenue and California-nexus thresholds.
  • An in-scope subsidiary can satisfy its obligation through a parent's consolidated report, but remains individually responsible for compliance.
  • First-year reports don't need to disaggregate California-specific data.
  • Out-of-scope subsidiaries may be voluntarily included in a parent's report but are excluded from the fee calculation.

Scope 3: Where Things Stand

The November 9 ruling sent SB 253's Scope 3 requirement back to the trial court. Until the trial court decides whether Scope 3 can be separated from the rest of the law, and any appeals play out, California will likely not require Scope 3 reporting.

For context, CARB's 2027 proposal had phased in five categories rather than all fifteen: purchased goods and services (1), fuel and energy-related activities (3), waste generated in operations (5), business travel (6), and employee commuting (7). Companies could exclude any that weren't relevant and voluntarily report others that were more material, using a principles-based approach (completeness, accuracy, relevance, transparency, consistency) rather than a fixed exclusion percentage. If Scope 3 returns on appeal, expect this framework to be the starting point.

The 5% Recalculation Threshold

If a future methodology, data, or boundary change shifts your total inventory more than 5% cumulatively from your base year, CARB's proposal would require recalculating prior years. This threshold applies to your entire inventory, not one scope or activity, so getting your first reporting year right matters more than it might seem.

Where CARB Still Has Work to Do

Open questions from the listening sessions (August 5 to September 9, 2026), ahead of the fall rulemaking package:

  • How a triggered recalculation actually gets applied: restating every intervening year, or just comparing against the base year
  • Whether and how the 5% threshold applies if Scope 3 eventually joins the inventory
  • Assurance provider qualifications and independence rules
  • Required 2027+ data fields and reporting formats
  • How CARB adjusts its regulations and guidance in response to the November 9 ruling

SB 261: Climate-Related Financial Risk Disclosure

SB 261 requires companies with more than $500 million in annual revenue doing business in California to publicly disclose climate-related financial risks and mitigation strategies. It remains paused, and no report is required while the injunction is in place.

Litigation Status

The Ninth Circuit paused SB 261 enforcement on November 18, 2025, and heard oral arguments in January 2026. On November 9, 2026, the court found SB 261 likely unconstitutional under the First Amendment and confirmed the hold stays in place. SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reporting was not affected.

The ruling is not a final decision on the law's constitutionality. Further proceedings, a rehearing request, or Supreme Court review could still change the outcome. The public docket opened December 1, 2025, and some companies have filed voluntarily.

What Would Be Required

If SB 261 is reinstated, companies would need to address five core areas, using TCFD, IFRS S2, or a recognized framework from a regulated exchange or government entity. Each report needs a comply-or-explain statement identifying the framework used and any omissions.

  • Reporting Framework: which framework was used and why
  • Governance: oversight structures for climate-related financial risk, including board involvement
  • Strategy: risks and opportunities across time horizons, and strategy resilience under future scenarios
  • Risk Management: how climate risk is identified, assessed, and integrated into broader risk processes
  • Metrics and Targets: what's used to track and manage material climate risk

Data flexibility: companies may use the most recent or best-available data, on a calendar-year or fiscal-year basis.

Scenario analysis: qualitative assessments are acceptable in the first reporting cycle; quantitative modeling is not required yet.

Emissions data: not required in the initial SB 261 report, to avoid duplicating SB 253.

Existing TCFD/ISSB reports: may satisfy SB 261 if published via the public docket with a comply-or-explain statement attached.

Exemptions: companies regulated by the California Department of Insurance or primarily engaged in insurance business, not-for-profits, and companies whose only California exposure is teleworkers.

Timeline of CARB's Climate Law Rulemaking

The California Legislature passed SB 253 and SB 261 in 2023, creating the most expansive climate disclosure laws in the country. SB 219, passed in August 2024, combined the two laws and gave CARB extra time to complete formal rulemaking.

  • May 29, 2025 – First public workshop; over 3,000 participants. Workshop recording | Presentation slides.
  • July 9, 2025 – Interim FAQ released. Since superseded, see the updated version below (November 17, 2025).
  • August 21, 2025 – Second workshop. Recording | Presentation slides.
  • October 10, 2025 – Draft Scope 1 and 2 reporting template and accompanying guidance memo released.
  • November 17, 2025 – Updated FAQ on California Climate Disclosure Requirements and Climate-Related Financial Risk Report Checklist published.
  • November 18, 2025 – Third workshop, updating definitions, exemptions, and deadlines. Recording | Presentation slides. Same day: Ninth Circuit pauses SB 261 enforcement.
  • February 26, 2026 – Board approves the Initial Regulation, establishing fees and the first-year deadline. Press release.
  • March 23, 2026 – Workshop on proposed GHG reporting requirements. Recording | Presentation slides.
  • July 21, 2026 – Fifth workshop, previewing 2027+ regulatory concepts: Scope 1/2 assurance and the proposed Scope 3 approach. Presentation slides.
  • August 5 – September 9, 2026 – Six sector-specific listening sessions.
  • September 1, 2026 – New reporting guidance ("Guidance for SB 253 2026 Reporting Submittals"), a voluntary online intake platform, and an instructional video released.
  • October 12, 2026 – Office of Administrative Law approved CARB's Initial Regulation of SB 253.‍
  • November 9, 2026: Ninth Circuit rules that SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reporting stays in effect, sends Scope 3 back to the trial court, and keeps the SB 261 stay in place.
  • ‍November 10, 2026: First SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reports due.‍
  • December 10, 2026 (upcoming): SB 253 fee assessment date; 60 days to pay.‍
  • 2027 (upcoming): Trial court decision on separating Scope 3 from the rest of SB 253, possible appeals, and CARB's formal rulemaking package (staff report, notice of public hearing, proposed regulatory text), followed by a 45-day public comment period.

What Companies Should Do Now

  1. Confirm your Scope 1 and 2 filing is complete. Reports were due November 10, 2026. If you haven't submitted yet, get your filing in as soon as possible.
  2. Plan for the fee. The assessment date is December 10, 2026, with 60 days to pay.
  3. Run a public-filing review. Submissions become public within 90 days, so confirm what you filed contains no commercially sensitive information.
  4. Document your methodology. Capture estimates, assumptions, boundaries, emission factors, and any changes. This matters more given the 5% recalculation threshold.
  5. Prepare for 2027 limited assurance. The ruling doesn't change this requirement. Identify evidence gaps and provider considerations now.
  6. Keep Scope 3 on your roadmap. Even if California pauses it, Scope 3 is part of the global GHG Protocol and feeds into CSRD, SBTi, CDP, EcoVadis, and customer supplier disclosures. For most companies it accounts for the majority of emissions, and the California mandate could return on appeal. Keep monitoring your Scope 3 activity data, and make a final call at your 2027 GHG kickoff.
  7. Keep SB 261 materials ready. No report is required while the injunction is in place, but your most recent climate-risk data, a qualitative TCFD or ISSB risk assessment, and governance documentation will save time if the law is reinstated or a customer or investor asks.

Final Thoughts on Meeting California Climate Disclosure Requirements in 2026

The November 9 ruling gives companies a clearer near-term picture. Scope 1 and 2 reporting under SB 253 is here to stay for now, assurance is coming in 2027, and SB 261 and Scope 3 are on hold while the courts finish their work.

What's still uncertain is how long that hold lasts. Treat your 2026 filing as the foundation for everything that follows, and keep your Scope 3 work moving so you're ready whichever way the courts and CARB go. Strong documentation and governance now will matter more once the 5% recalculation threshold and assurance requirements take effect.

At Good.Lab, we help companies build GHG measurement and reporting processes that hold up under CARB's requirements and the other frameworks that rely on the same data.

‍Talk to an expert to plan your 2027 reporting and Scope 3 roadmap.

‍

Long heading is what you see here in this feature section

Learn more about our approach to emerging regulations and including SB 261, SB 263 and complete mandatory reporting with ease.

Talk to an expert

Not sure where to start? That's exactly where we come in.

Most of our clients came to us with more questions than answers. That's fine. Tell us what you're navigating and we'll tell you what we'd do first.

Talk to an expert